Welcome back to another installment of Federation Fridays, where we once again travel back to the glory days of the World Wrestling Federation to revisit a wrestler who, in my opinion, deserved a much better opportunity than the one he received. This week’s subject is Jean-Pierre LaFitte, a pirate who sailed into the WWF in 1995, had one of the best matches of the year against Bret Hart, and then practically disappeared before the character ever had a chance to reach its potential.
Before becoming LaFitte, Carl Ouellet was already familiar to WWF audiences as Pierre, one half of The Quebecers alongside Jacques Rougeau. The duo enjoyed quite a bit of success in the tag team division, capturing the WWF Tag Team Championship three times and establishing themselves as one of the better heel teams of the New Generation era. And they were certainly one of my favorites at that time. Following Rougeau’s departure, however, Ouellet needed something new, and the WWF decided that what this talented Canadian wrestler really needed was an eyepatch, some pirate clothing, and a new identity.
And you know what? I liked it.

A Pirate in the New Generation
Jean-Pierre LaFitte made his WWF debut in the spring of 1995, supposedly a descendant of the famous pirate Jean Lafitte, and he arrived looking like somebody who had wandered straight out of a swashbuckling adventure movie. With his eyepatch, distinctive ring attire, and powerful physique, he certainly stood out from the rest of the roster.
Now, I realize that 1995 WWF isn’t exactly remembered as the company’s finest creative period. This was the era of wrestling dentists, garbage men, hog farmers, and enough occupational gimmicks to fill out an entire small-town employment directory. A pirate probably sounds ridiculous when you put him alongside some of those characters, but I thought LaFitte worked because Ouellet was actually convincing in the role.
More importantly, the man could wrestle.
LaFitte wasn’t simply some big guy dressed in a costume who lumbered around the ring waiting to hit his finishing move. He was surprisingly agile for his size, could throw himself around with reckless abandon, and possessed the sort of physical offense that made his matches entertaining. His Cannonball, a diving senton from the top rope, was an impressive finishing maneuver, especially for a man of his build.
I thought the WWF had something with him, and for a few months, it appeared that the company might have agreed.
The Pirate Steals from the Hitman
LaFitte’s most memorable storyline began during the summer of 1995 when he developed a rather unfortunate habit of stealing things belonging to Bret Hart.
The Hitman was famous for giving his mirrored sunglasses to young fans at ringside, and LaFitte decided that stealing those glasses was an excellent way to get under Bret’s skin. He eventually took things a step further by stealing Hart’s trademark leather ring jacket, which naturally didn’t sit too well with the former WWF Champion.
It was a simple storyline, but sometimes simple is all you need. LaFitte was a pirate, pirates steal things, and Bret Hart wasn’t particularly interested in having his belongings stolen. You didn’t need a complicated explanation or six weeks of backstage interviews to understand why these two men wanted to fight.
And the fact that the WWF was putting LaFitte into a program with Bret Hart was encouraging. Bret was one of the company’s biggest stars and arguably its finest wrestler, so getting an opportunity to work with him on pay-per-view was a pretty significant step for somebody who had only been using his new character for a few months.
That opportunity came on September 24, 1995, at In Your House 3: Triple Header.
The Match That Should Have Changed Everything
I’ll go ahead and say it: Bret Hart versus Jean-Pierre LaFitte was the match of the night.
The pay-per-view was built around Diesel and Shawn Michaels teaming against Yokozuna and The British Bulldog with three championships at stake, but the match that I remember most fondly was the one involving a Canadian wrestling legend and a pirate who had stolen his jacket.
And they absolutely delivered.
Bret didn’t even wait for the match to properly begin before launching himself through the ropes onto LaFitte with a suicide dive. It was an unusually aggressive opening from the Hitman, and it immediately established that he wasn’t interested in having a friendly wrestling contest with the man who had been tormenting him.
What followed was an outstanding physical match that gave LaFitte an opportunity to demonstrate just how good he really was. Bret brought his usual excellence, but LaFitte more than held his own, using his strength, surprising agility, and willingness to take some nasty bumps to make the encounter feel like a genuine fight.
The two exchanged some tremendous offense, including LaFitte taking a brutal trip into the steel steps and Bret absorbing plenty of punishment himself. LaFitte even attempted his Cannonball from the top rope, only for Hart to avoid it, and the match continued with both men fighting for control.
What I appreciate most about the encounter is that LaFitte didn’t look out of place sharing the ring with Bret Hart. Quite the opposite, actually. He looked like somebody who belonged in a prominent position on the roster, and Bret gave him enough offense to make the eventual outcome feel earned rather than inevitable.
After more than sixteen minutes, Bret finally secured the victory with the Sharpshooter and reclaimed his stolen jacket.
LaFitte lost the match, but he certainly didn’t look like a loser coming out of it. For my money, he had just delivered the finest performance of his WWF singles career, and I thought it should have been the beginning of something bigger.
Unfortunately, it wasn’t.
A Pirate Without a Ship
LaFitte’s momentum never really recovered after the Bret Hart program, and his WWF career came to an end not long afterward. Stories have circulated over the years about backstage disagreements involving members of The Kliq, particularly a dispute surrounding a match with Diesel in Montreal, although I won’t pretend to know everything that happened behind the scenes.
What I do know is that the WWF had a talented wrestler who had just proven he could deliver an excellent match against one of the best performers in the business, and rather than building on that success, the company allowed him to slip away.
That’s what disappointed me most about Jean-Pierre LaFitte. I didn’t necessarily expect him to become WWF Champion, and I certainly wasn’t demanding that he headline WrestleMania, but I thought he could have developed into a terrific upper-midcard heel. Give him some meaningful rivalries, let him work with the better wrestlers on the roster, and see how far the character could go.
Instead, his pirate adventure ended almost as quickly as it began.
The Pirate’s Revenge
Fortunately, Carl Ouellet’s wrestling story didn’t end in 1995. After years of working in different promotions, he experienced a remarkable career resurgence as PCO, the seemingly indestructible monster who became a cult favorite on the independent scene and eventually captured the Ring of Honor World Championship. Watching him reinvent himself so many years after his original WWF run was genuinely satisfying, especially considering how easily he could have become another forgotten name from the New Generation era.
But whenever I think about Ouellet, I still remember Jean-Pierre LaFitte, the eyepatch, the stolen jacket, and that tremendous match against Bret Hart at In Your House 3.
Maybe the pirate gimmick was never destined to become a major attraction, but I would have loved to see the WWF give it a proper chance. Ouellet had the talent, he had the presence, and for one night in September 1995, he proved he could hang with the very best.
Jean-Pierre LaFitte deserved better, and thirty-one years later, I still believe it.

