Wrestling Columns

Federation Fridays #8: What the Hell Is a Goldust?

Stinger
Federation Fridays banner

Most wrestling debuts are pretty simple: then, now, forever. Some new guy walks through the curtain, his music hits, Vince McMahon (back then) or whoever screams his name at you, and then you spend the next five or ten minutes figuring out whether the guy is any good.

Goldust wasn’t like that.

Hell, by the time Goldust actually wrestled his first WWF match at In Your House 4 in October 1995, we’d already spent weeks trying to figure out what the hell we were looking at. There were these weird vignettes with this gold-painted guy talking like an old Hollywood movie star, staring into the camera for slightly too long and quoting old movies from Hollywood’s “Golden Age” (lol, get it?). I was nine years old at the time, so obviously I had no damn clue what any of this meant. I’m not entirely sure most adults watching WWF in 1995 knew what the hell it meant either.

And that’s what made it so interesting.

This was the New Generation WWF, where figuring out somebody’s gimmick usually wasn’t particularly difficult. Duke “the Dumpster” Droese carried a trash can because he was a garbage man. Bob Holly was “Sparkplug” with checkered flag attire because he was a race car driver. Henry Godwinn carried around a bucket of slop because he was a hog farmer. Isaac Yankem was a giant, angry dentist for some reason, so his name had to include the “I Yank ’em.” Nothing about any of it was subtle.

Then there’s Goldust.

What the hell is a Goldust? Is it Gol-dust, or gold-ust? And why the hell do we all say golddust when there’s clearly no second d in it?

Federation Fridays #8 What the Hell is a Goldust?

That’s what I remember about those original vignettes more than anything else. I didn’t know what this guy was supposed to be, but I wanted to find out.

And here’s the kicker: underneath all that gold paint wasn’t some rookie WWF had found and decided to saddle with another ridiculous New Generation gimmick. It was Dustin Rhodes.

Dustin damn Rhodes.

Dusty Rhodes’ son had already spent years in WCW, after a short early 90s stint in WWF as Dustin Rhodes, basically looking and wrestling exactly like you’d expect Dusty Rhodes’ son to look and wrestle. Straightforward Texas babyface, boots and jeans outside the ring, simple trunks in it, good wrestler, nothing particularly weird about him. Then he comes back to the WWF, and apparently the conversation went something like, “Okay Dustin, forget all that shit. We’re going to paint you gold, put you in a wig and have you act like a sexually ambiguous movie star.”

And somehow this was a fantastic idea.

I love wrestling.

Goldust finally made his in-ring debut at In Your House 4 in Winnipeg on October 22, 1995, and even the entrance immediately told you this wasn’t going to be a normal debut. Gold lighting, glitter, photographers taking pictures as he made his way toward the ring. The whole thing looked more like a movie premiere than somebody coming out to have a wrestling match.

Granted, this was 1995 WWF, so elaborate and stupid gimmicks weren’t exactly unusual. Outside of the ones already mentioned, damn Mantaur existed. I still don’t know what the fuck Mantaur was supposed to be. Half man, half bull, all shitty wrestling gimmick, I suppose. And there was a pirate running around at this time too.

Anyway, Goldust.

His first opponent was Marty Jannetty, who had recently returned to the WWF, and that’s actually a pretty damn good choice for a debut opponent. Jannetty could work and move around enough to make the match interesting without taking attention away from the entire reason the match existed: What the hell is Goldust?

And that’s really what you’re finding out here.

Goldust isn’t doing anything revolutionary from a wrestling standpoint, but Dustin is already completely committed to the character. Everything is slower and more deliberate. He poses. He stalls. He gets uncomfortably close to Jannetty. Even normal wrestling moves feel a little different because of how he’s carrying himself between them.

That’s something I don’t think gets enough credit when people talk about gimmicks. Anybody can put on a costume. Hell, WWF proved that repeatedly during this exact period. What makes a gimmick work is when the wrestler convinces you that’s actually who he is when the bell rings. Dustin Rhodes disappeared when that gold paint went on, and Goldust seemed like a completely different person.

Eventually Jannetty goes up top for the flying fist, Goldust gets his boot up, and shortly afterward hits the Curtain Call (which was both an awesome move and fantastic name for a finisher) for the win.

That’s it.

And no, I’m not going to sit here and tell you that Goldust versus Marty Jannetty at In Your House 4 is some hidden classic that you’ve got to immediately go watch. It’s not. Nobody is digging through their old Coliseum Video collection thirty years later because they desperately need another viewing of Goldust versus Marty Jannetty. Besides, it’s quicker (but not as fun) to pull it up on YouTube… which I’ve done for you and included below, because I’m a nice person like that.

But that’s also not the point.

This wasn’t supposed to be a five-star wrestling match. It was supposed to introduce Goldust, and it did exactly that.

What’s funny is that this version of Goldust is actually pretty tame compared to what was coming. Within a few months he’s screwing with Razor Ramon in ways that probably confused the absolute hell out of nine-year-old me, Marlena joins him, and he beats Razor for the Intercontinental Championship at the 1996 Royal Rumble. Then you’ve got the cigar smoke, director’s chair, mind games and all the other weird shit that made Goldust Goldust. And man, Marlena… good lord have mercy. People kind of forget about her when looking back on this period because Sable comes in a few months later, but damn, Marlena was a smokeshow in her usually somewhat revealing outfits. Little me loved her, and big me is still rather fond of her.

WWF Marlena

Ok, I got distracted for a second there. Back to our scheduled programming, and the subject matter was supposed to be Goldust, not Marlena. So back to the point I set out to make, the character is already here.

Dustin didn’t come out looking like a guy trying to figure out how this gimmick was supposed to work. He came through the curtain already being Goldust.

And that’s probably the craziest thing about the whole character when you look back at it now. Imagine somebody pitching this shit in 1995.

“We’ve got Dusty Rhodes’ son.”

“Great. What are we going to do with him?”

“Paint him gold.”

“Okay…”

“Put him in a wig.”

“Uh-huh.”

“And make him an unsettling, sexually ambiguous Hollywood movie character that quotes old classic movies.”

“Dammit, that’s good shit pal.”

It sounds like exactly the sort of New Generation gimmick that should’ve disappeared six months later, if that long. Except Goldust didn’t disappear.

The garbage man disappeared. The dentist disappeared and came back as a fake Diesel, then disappeared again before finally returning as an all time great gimmick in Kane, but that’s a subject for another Friday. Mantaur sure as hell disappeared.

Goldust survived.

And not only did he survive, the character became bigger than whatever stupid gimmick description somebody originally wrote down on a piece of paper. There were wrestlers who had better matches than Dustin Rhodes, wrestlers who won more championships, and wrestlers who main-evented much bigger shows, but there aren’t many wrestling characters from 1995 that you can show somebody thirty years later and have them immediately know who they’re looking at.

Goldust is one of them.

And it all started here at this In Your House almost 31 years ago.

Well, technically it started with those weird-ass vignettes, but you know what I mean.

Agree, disagree, or remember watching Goldust debut yourself? Let me know in the comments below.

Stinger's avatar

Stinger

Stinger has been writing wrestling columns since June 2004. A veteran of the wrestling media scene as a former columnist at WrestlingHeadlines/Lords of Pain, NoDQ and others, he has watched this business go through every cycle, controversy, and reinvention imaginable and still has not managed to quit it. Now back as a columnist exclusively for Titanquisitor!

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x