The Adventures of Robin Hood (1938) Review (Throwback Thursday #19)
Directors: Michael Curtiz and William Keighley
Written By: Norman Reilly Raine and Seton I. Miller
Starring: Errol Flynn, Olivia de Havilland, Basil Rathbone, Claude Rains, Patric Knowles, Eugene Pallette, Alan Hale Sr., Melville Cooper, Una O’Connor, Ian Hunter
Release Date: May 14, 1938 (United States)
Rating: Not Rated (released before the modern MPAA ratings system)
Welcome back to another Throwback Thursday! This week, our resident Goddess of Cinema, Theia, is taking the reins and bringing us along for a colorful Technicolor adventure through Sherwood Forest with the classic The Adventures of Robin Hood, starring Errol Flynn and Olivia de Havilland.
I have a weakness for a gentleman who knows his way around a sword, isn’t afraid to stand up to a tyrant, and can manage to do both while looking rather handsome in green tights. Errol Flynn happens to meet all three qualifications in The Adventures of Robin Hood, and I must confess that I’ve never found much reason to complain about it.
Released by Warner Bros. in 1938, this colorful adventure has been entertaining audiences for nearly ninety years, and I think it remains one of the most enjoyable films to come out of Hollywood’s Golden Age (especially in the early pre-40s period). It has a dashing hero, a beautiful heroine, some thoroughly unpleasant villains, and enough sword fighting to satisfy anyone who enjoys a good old-fashioned adventure. I also appreciate that it doesn’t spend much time trying to convince us that Robin Hood is anything other than a hero. He’s a good man fighting against some very bad people, and many times that’s exactly the sort of story I want to watch.
Our story takes place in medieval England, where King Richard the Lionheart is away and his brother, Prince John, has taken advantage of the situation to make life thoroughly miserable for the Saxon population. Taxes are excessive and the Norman nobility behaves as though ordinary people exist solely for its benefit. Anyone who objects is liable to find himself in serious trouble, and so Sir Robin of Locksley (played by Errol Flynn) objects rather enthusiastically.
After openly challenging Prince John’s authority, Robin becomes an outlaw and gathers a band of followers in Sherwood Forest, and this is where they begin stealing from the wealthy and corrupt to help the people suffering under John’s rule. Naturally, this makes him unpopular with the prince and his associates, especially Sir Guy of Gisbourne, who would very much like to see our handsome outlaw captured and killed.
Lady Marian (Olivia de Havilland) initially sees Robin as little more than a troublesome criminal and not a hero. She’s been raised among the Norman aristocracy and hasn’t given much thought to what life is like for the people outside of her privileged world. Her opinion starts to change as she witnesses the cruelty being carried out in Prince John’s name, and she gradually discovers that Robin might be a far more honorable gentleman than the nobles who consider themselves his betters.
The story moves quickly and with plenty of ambushes, escapes, sword fights, and some occasional romantic encounters between Robin and Marian. Anyone familiar with the Robin Hood legend will know roughly where things are heading, but I don’t think that matters very much. I’ve seen this film before, I know what Robin is going to do, and I still enjoy watching him do it.
Errol Flynn was so perfectly suited to play Robin Hood that I have difficulty imagining anyone else in the role (although of course plenty of actors have certainly tried over the years and none hold a candle). He’s handsome, athletic, charming, and just arrogant enough to make you wonder whether he might occasionally benefit from being knocked down a peg or two. Of course, that would require somebody to catch him first, and the poor soldiers of Nottingham don’t have much luck with that.
I love how much fun Flynn appears to be having. Robin laughs at danger and he takes pleasure in insulting men who could have him executed. And he also seems perfectly delighted whenever an opportunity arises to embarrass Prince John or Sir Guy. One of my favorite things about his performance is the way he can make an outrageous act of defiance seem almost casual, as though confronting a room full of armed enemies is simply another pleasant way to spend an afternoon.
He also has a smooth way of delivering his lines with a sort of mischievous smile suggesting he knows something everyone else doesn’t. I can understand why his enemies find him infuriating. Imagine being an important nobleman, surrounded by guards, only to have this grinning fellow in green announce that he’s going to rob you and then proceed to do exactly that.
Flynn’s Robin isn’t simply showing off, though. He’s actually concerned about the people Prince John is mistreating, and we see that in the way he deals with those who need his help. I think that’s important because, without it, he’d be a rather entertaining nuisance instead of the hero of the story.
Olivia de Havilland is lovely as Lady Marian, and I don’t mean simply because she looks beautiful in those elaborate costumes (although she certainly does). She gives Marian a quiet intelligence that becomes more apparent as the story progresses, and I enjoy watching her gradually lose patience with the behavior of the men she’s been taught to respect and the life/world that’s she’s been brought up in.
Her early scenes with Robin are especially entertaining because she isn’t immediately impressed by him. He’s charming, certainly, but from her perspective he’s also a criminal who seems to enjoy causing trouble. Flynn and de Havilland play wonderfully off one another, and their exchanges become warmer as Marian begins to understand what Robin is actually fighting for.
I also like that Marian doesn’t simply stand around waiting for Robin to rescue her. She becomes involved in helping him, even though doing so puts her in a dangerous position. There are limits to what the screenplay allows her to do, and I wouldn’t have minded seeing more of the story from her perspective, but de Havilland makes the most of the role.
And since I know my esteemed editor will undoubtedly have something to say about this, yes, Gary, Olivia de Havilland is extraordinarily beautiful in this film. You may put away the enormous WOULD sign; I have already acknowledged it.
Claude Rains is a delight as Prince John, a man who seems to believe the entire kingdom exists for his personal convenience. He’s arrogant, spoiled, and so thoroughly convinced of his own importance that I sometimes find myself laughing before he’s even finished speaking. Rains has a marvelous talent for making a character unpleasant without having to raise his voice every few seconds, and I love the expressions he gives Robin whenever the outlaw has managed to humiliate him yet again.
Basil Rathbone’s Sir Guy of Gisbourne is a different sort of villain. He’s cold, proud, and considerably more dangerous with a sword than Prince John would ever care to be. Rathbone carries himself with such rigid dignity that putting him opposite Flynn is almost unfair. Robin is forever smiling, laughing, and treating danger as an amusement, while Sir Guy looks as though he considers smiling a personal weakness.
Their rivalry leads to some of the film’s best scenes, including the famous sword fight near the end. Rathbone was an accomplished fencer, and it certainly shows. The two men move through the castle with swords flashing, shadows stretching across the walls, and enough excitement to make me forget that I already know how the fight ends. I’ve always loved a good sword fight, and this one is among the finest Hollywood ever put on screen.
Melville Cooper also deserves a mention as the Sheriff of Nottingham, who is wonderfully unpleasant and frequently rather cowardly. He provides some welcome comedy, especially when things begin going wrong for Prince John’s little collection of scoundrels.
I rather enjoy all three villains, which I suppose says something about the quality of the performances. I wouldn’t want to spend an evening in their company, mind you, but they’re delightful people to watch from the safety of my own chair.
Robin’s Merry Men are a cheerful bunch, and I enjoy the scenes where we get to spend time with them away from the castle and Prince John’s scheming. Alan Hale is excellent as Little John, and Eugene Pallette makes a wonderfully gruff Friar Tuck. Patric Knowles is also quite good as Will Scarlett, although I wish the film had given him a little more to do.
The scenes in Sherwood have a warmth and charm that’s both appealing and endearing. The men laugh, feast, argue, and generally seem to enjoy their lives despite the fact that they’re outlaws with the authorities constantly trying to arrest them. I said appealing, but I suppose the novelty of sleeping outdoors would probably wear off after a few weeks and it likely wouldn’t be nearly as pleasant as these gentlemen (or you might say merry men) make it look.
The action scenes are great fun as well. I love the forest ambushes, the archery contest, and the way Robin seems to find himself surrounded by armed men at every possible opportunity. There’s plenty of running, jumping, swinging, and sword fighting, and the performers throw themselves into it with an enthusiasm that I find difficult to resist.
Of course, the action looks different from what we’re accustomed to seeing in modern films. The fighting is more theatrical, and there are moments when you can tell that everyone is carefully following the choreography. That doesn’t bother me. I rather enjoy seeing the performers moving through those elaborate sets, and there’s a certain pleasure in watching a well-staged sword fight where you can actually follow what everyone is doing.
I could happily spend an entire afternoon admiring the way The Adventures of Robin Hood looks. The greens of Sherwood Forest, the colorful costumes, the castle interiors, and those enormous banquet scenes are all gorgeous, and the Technicolor photography gives everything the appearance of a beautifully illustrated storybook.
I especially love the costumes. Flynn’s green outfit has become practically inseparable from the image of Robin Hood, while de Havilland looks lovely in her gowns. Prince John and his fellow nobles are dressed in enough rich fabric and decoration to make their wealth impossible to miss, which I suppose is rather appropriate considering how much of it they’ve been taking from everybody else.
The sets are just as enjoyable to look at. The castle interiors have enormous halls, stone staircases, and plenty of places for people to hide or conduct a sword fight, while Sherwood Forest looks like somewhere I might enjoy spending a pleasant afternoon. Provided, of course, that nobody was trying to arrest me.
William Keighley began directing the film before Michael Curtiz took over during production, and I’ve always found that rather interesting because the finished picture doesn’t feel as though it has been pieced together by two different directors. Whatever difficulties may have occurred during filming, the result is a handsome production that moves along at a good pace and looks marvelous from beginning to end.
I know that some viewers prefer historical films to look a little more realistic, but I’ve never felt that Robin Hood needed to resemble a documentary about medieval England. Give me the colorful costumes, the beautiful forest, and the enormous castle with a staircase conveniently placed for a sword fight. I’m perfectly happy.
Now, darling readers, we must discuss the music, and I promise I haven’t forgotten that I recently spent a good deal of time praising Bernard Herrmann’s score for The Ghost and Mrs. Muir. I do seem to have developed a habit of falling in love with movie soundtracks, but I can hardly be expected to apologize when Hollywood keeps giving me such lovely things to listen to.
Erich Wolfgang Korngold’s music for The Adventures of Robin Hood is magnificent. I love the way the orchestra seems to burst into life whenever Robin charges into another adventure, and the quieter passages accompanying his scenes with Marian are just as beautiful. The music is such a big part of the film that I sometimes find myself paying more attention to it than to whatever is happening on screen.
Korngold knew how to make an adventure sound exciting, and he wasn’t afraid to use the full orchestra to do it. The brass, strings, and percussion give the action scenes a tremendous sense of movement, while the romantic themes are softer and more delicate. I also enjoy how the music changes as the story moves between the forest, the castle, and Robin’s encounters with Marian setting a different tone for each visual change.
The score won an Academy Award, and I wouldn’t argue with that decision because it’s one of my favorite things about the film, and I can’t imagine watching this version of Robin Hood without it.
Between Korngold’s orchestra, Errol Flynn’s smile, and Olivia de Havilland looking absolutely lovely, I do believe the filmmakers were determined to spoil me.
I think The Adventures of Robin Hood is every bit as entertaining today as it probably was in 1938; now having said that, I can understand why some modern viewers might have reservations about it.
The characters are fairly straightforward, the villains are unmistakably villainous, and Robin is such an admirable fellow that there’s rarely much doubt about whose side we’re supposed to be on. That’s really kind of the point of the story, but the nuance of modern times wants everything to be more shades of grey and this film is more black and white in the morality department. The performances are also more theatrical than those in most modern adventure films.
I don’t mind any of that because to me not every story needs to leave me questioning the motives of every character, and I certainly don’t require a complicated explanation for why Prince John is a thoroughly unpleasant man. I simply want to see Errol Flynn make a fool of the villains, rescue the unfortunate, and win the heart of a beautiful woman along the way and not have a portion of the film trying to get me to see things through John’s eyes in a desperate attempt to make me view him as anything other than a terrible person.
I do wish Marian had been given a little more independence, and a few of the supporting characters could have used additional scenes. Those are minor complaints though, and I can’t say they interfere much with my enjoyment of the film.
The thing that matters most to me is that I still have fun watching it and that’s kinda the point of watching an adventure film. I laugh at Robin’s antics and enjoy the sword fights, and find myself smiling whenever Korngold’s music swells. For a film that’s been around since 1938, I think that’s a rather good recommendation.
I’ve seen a lot of adventure films over the years, and The Adventures of Robin Hood remains one of my favorites. Errol Flynn is marvelous in the title role, Olivia de Havilland makes a lovely Marian, and Claude Rains and Basil Rathbone are so entertaining as the villains that I almost wish they had a few more scenes together.
It’s also one of those films I enjoy recommending to people who haven’t spent much time exploring older Hollywood movies. The story is easy to follow, the action is entertaining, and the Technicolor photography is beautiful. You don’t need to know anything about the history of cinema to enjoy watching Robin Hood embarrass Prince John, and you certainly don’t need to be a film historian to appreciate a good sword fight.
I suspect I’ll be returning to Sherwood Forest again before very long. After all, where else can a lady spend an evening in the company of a handsome outlaw, enjoy a magnificent orchestral performance, and watch a collection of arrogant noblemen get exactly what they deserve?
This is an enormously entertaining adventure with Errol Flynn at his most charming and Olivia de Havilland at her loveliest, and it has beautiful Technicolor photography that holds up almost 90 years later, and a score that deserves to be heard at full volume. I adore it.
The Adventures of Robin Hood gets a five out of five: EXALTED.

If you’ve enjoyed our little adventure through Sherwood Forest, I invite you to explore more of our Throwback Thursday archives, where we revisit the classics, celebrate old Hollywood, and occasionally discover a film we’d rather forget. You never know what cinematic treasure (or disaster) we’ll uncover next!
