Game Columns

The Sunday Sermon: Bloodborne and the Knowledge That Costs You Everything

Gary Smith
The Sunday Sermon banner

Welcome back to The Sunday Sermon. A couple of weeks ago, we looked FromSoftware’s Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice. Today, and because it’s the first Sunday in October, we’re looking at another FromSoftware classic… Bloodborne. If you’re wondering what October has to do with anything, it doesn’t; I just associate the game with Halloween time because that’s why I first played it.

Let’s get to it.

There is a stat in Bloodborne called Insight.

It measures, in a sense, how much you know. As you encounter bosses, Great Ones, and secrets the game has been hiding from you, your Insight rises, and as it does, the world begins to change. Creatures that were invisible become visible. Sounds you couldn’t hear before start bleeding in at the edges of your perception. Things that were always there, just beyond your ability to perceive them, suddenly become impossible to ignore. The more you know, the more you see, and the more you see, the less the world looks like anything a sane person would want to live in.

That is not just a clever game mechanic. That is Bloodborne.

FromSoftware’s 2015 masterpiece is set in the gothic city of Yharnam, a place built on secrets that almost nobody walking its streets fully understands. Long before the Hunter arrives, scholars from an institution called Byrgenwerth began exploring the ancient labyrinth beneath Yharnam and discovered evidence of something far beyond ordinary human understanding. There were beings of immense cosmic power, the Great Ones, and there was an eldritch truth about the universe that humanity had somehow gone its entire existence without being able to see.

These weren’t gods in any comforting sense. They weren’t offering moral guidance or promising anybody a better life after death. They were simply enormous, ancient and incomprehensible, existing on a level of reality that human beings could barely perceive, much less understand. Master Willem and the scholars of Byrgenwerth became obsessed with that understanding. Willem believed humanity could transcend its limitations by gaining greater knowledge, by acquiring metaphorical and eventually very literal “eyes” that would allow human beings to perceive what had always been hidden from them.

Not everyone agreed on how humanity should get there. Laurence, one of Willem’s students, broke with his master and pursued the power of the Old Blood instead. Willem warned him to fear it, but Laurence left Byrgenwerth and eventually founded the Healing Church, which built its influence around blood ministration. Different methods, different institutions, but underneath both was the same basic desire: humanity as it currently existed wasn’t enough. There had to be a way to become something more.

And Yharnam became what you walk into at the beginning of the game—a city full of people transforming into beasts, a Healing Church built on secrets and terrible experiments, and a night of horrors caused by generations of people reaching toward things they never completely understood.

Ecclesiastes 1:18 is the verse I keep coming back to for this one.

“For with much wisdom comes much sorrow; the more knowledge, the more grief.”

The Preacher in Ecclesiastes has pursued wisdom about as far as a person can take it, and what that wisdom has given him is not simple peace or contentment. It has given him a clearer view of how temporary everything is, how much of human striving amounts to chasing after things that eventually disappear anyway. He sees more than the person who never bothers asking these questions, but seeing more doesn’t necessarily make him happier. Sometimes understanding something means losing the comfortable version of it you had before.

That is basically the experience of gaining Insight in Bloodborne. The world doesn’t suddenly become horrible because your Insight went up. It was already horrible. Those enormous Amygdalae weren’t created when you gained enough Insight to see them hanging from buildings. They were there the entire time. You simply couldn’t perceive them. Knowledge didn’t create the horror. Knowledge removed the protection of not knowing it was there.

But Bloodborne takes that idea farther than simply saying ignorance is bliss. Master Willem doesn’t just want to understand the Great Ones. He wants humanity to transcend itself. Laurence pursues that same basic dream through blood rather than Insight, and the Healing Church eventually takes the pursuit into places neither wisdom nor morality should have allowed it to go. Human beings become experiments. Entire institutions are built around secrets. The people of Yharnam trust the Church to heal them without understanding what they’re being given or where it came from, and the miracle slowly becomes a nightmare.

The beast plague isn’t simply the punishment for learning too much. That’s important, because Bloodborne isn’t telling us that opening a book is going to turn us into werewolves. The disaster comes from what people do with what they’ve discovered, and from their refusal to accept that perhaps there are limits they shouldn’t cross simply because crossing them might be possible.

Nowhere is that clearer than the Fishing Hamlet.

Byrgenwerth’s scholars and the hunters who served their interests encountered the remains of the Great One Kos and descended on the village in search of knowledge. What happened there was an atrocity. The villagers were killed and violated in the scholars’ search for eyes and understanding, and the consequences of what happened at the Fishing Hamlet echo through the Hunter’s Nightmare long after the people responsible are gone. The curse that follows the hunters isn’t some random cosmic accident. It is tied directly to what they did there, and to people who had become so consumed with discovering the truth that other human beings had become little more than material for their research.

That’s where Bloodborne and Ecclesiastes really connect for me, because neither one is making the argument that ignorance is somehow a virtue. Ecclesiastes doesn’t tell us to stop learning, and Bloodborne isn’t a warning against curiosity. The problem is the belief that human beings should have no limits at all, that every boundary exists only because nobody clever enough has figured out how to cross it yet.

Willem looked toward the cosmos and wanted humanity to rise to the level of the Great Ones. Laurence believed blood could take humanity somewhere Willem’s Insight could not. The Healing Church kept pushing further, experimenting on people in pursuit of communion and transcendence. Others followed them and went further still. Again and again, somebody discovers that there is another door and decides that the fact the door exists must mean they’re supposed to open it.

Nobody seems willing to consider that perhaps being human wasn’t a problem that needed to be solved.

What strikes me about Ecclesiastes 1:18 is that the Preacher doesn’t tell you not to pursue wisdom. He doesn’t say stay ignorant and you’ll be happy. He tells you that wisdom has a cost, because understanding more means seeing things you might have been happier not seeing. The grief that comes with understanding is real, but wisdom also means recognizing the difference between seeking truth and believing that enough knowledge can somehow make you more than what you were created to be.

By the end of Ecclesiastes, after all the searching, questioning, and examination of what human beings spend their lives chasing, the conclusion is almost impossibly simple: fear God and keep his commandments.

Not because ignorance is bliss. Not because curiosity is sinful. Not because we’re supposed to spend our lives refusing to ask difficult questions. It’s because genuine wisdom eventually requires enough humility to understand that you are not God. There are things greater than you, things you will never completely understand, and limits to what human beings can know and control. Wisdom isn’t pretending those mysteries don’t exist. Wisdom is knowing that discovering something doesn’t automatically give you the right to possess it, control it or remake yourself with it.

That is the lesson Yharnam learned far too late.

The scholars wanted eyes. The Church wanted blood. Everybody wanted transcendence. Everybody wanted to see beyond the limits of ordinary human existence, and almost nobody stopped to ask whether those limits might exist for a reason. By the time they understood what their pursuit had cost them, Yharnam was already lost.

October is a good time to think about what we’re willing to trade for the things we think we want to know, but maybe the better question is what we’re willing to become in order to know them.

See you next Sunday.

Gary Smith's avatar

Gary Smith

Gary is Owner and Editor-in-Chief of Titanquisitor.com. He's usually posting articles and reviews and doing all the back-end stuff. He likes to play video games, gardening, woodworking, reading, walking and watching college sports (Roll Tide Roll).

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x